Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ian Davidson's avatar

Very good analysis. Consider this small example in East Renfrewshire. Both MSPS are now SNP. Both are Scot Gov Ministers. So, forget about asking either to take on any criticism of Scot Gov policies or indeed anything remotely controversial. Fall back to 7 List MSPs which include 3 national party leaders & one Depute PO. If I/we are lucky, I have identified and made contact with 2/7 List MSPs who might be receptive to taking up issues? That's it! The local MP is Labour, Junior UK Gov Minister. Democracy, wow!

Fraser - Scotland's Potential.'s avatar

The Easterhouse turnout figure runs through everything here. You can draw a straight line from 40% non-participation to life expectancy, to the drug death rate, to the ScotWind rental income leaving the communities that look at the turbines every day. The 2014 movement showed those people will engage when the stakes feel material rather than constitutional. The problem isn't that they've given up on politics - it's that politics has given up on delivering anything they can see.

The governing programme question your piece leaves open is the one that matters most: what makes participation feel rational again for Easterhouse? My answer is material change first, political trust second. A community that owns the turbines, has stable housing, can get drug treatment without a six-month wait - that community has a reason to show up. Not because independence is on the ballot but because the last five years produced something visible.

One thing worth adding to your ScotWind analysis: the TNUoS grid connection charging regime is as significant a barrier as the rental rate. Scottish renewable producers pay ten to twenty times more than English ones to connect to the grid - some ScotWind projects that had permission have been pushed out of the queue entirely because of it. The rental rate argument and the grid charging argument are both extraction mechanisms. The programme needs both as Westminster asks, not just one.

1 more comment...

Ready for more?